The theory of Depressive Realism suggests that individuals with clinical depression make more accurate inferences of the world around them than non-depressed individuals. In literature, the term has been applied to the writing of Michel Houellebecq by the critic Ben Jeffrey, who argues that the value of his work comes from his repeated portrayals of his characters’ failure to transcend their surroundings, and their mortality, which imbues his novels with a greater degree of honesty and truth than can be found in less rigidly materialistic writing.
In This Is The Ritual, his first
collection of short fiction, Rob Doyle writes with a level of
bleakness and savagery which would sit comfortably alongside Houellebecq’s
early work, and yet, at times, his writing is able to transcend the ‘radical
resignation’ of Atomised or Platform. His characters achieve a
sort of transcendence through their grotesqueness, the frustration of their
ambitions elevating them to a surreal level of despair. The overall
effect is brutal, at times hard to cope with, but ultimately compelling.
Perhaps the most vivid example of his style comes in Anus – Black Sun. Off his head after a warehouse party,
the narrator finds himself in front of his computer, trawling through
increasingly debased websites, until, 'lodged
in the murky peripheries of a horrendous, low-end porn site,'
he discovers a window, 'surrounded by ads so vile I felt soiled whenever my eyes strayed to them' . The video, filmed on a single, static camera, under harsh,
artificial lighting, consists of a 43 minute shot of a woman’s anus, with no
narrative or mis en scene. The
ability to skip forward through the film has been disabled, and yet the narrator
finds himself transfixed. In his chemically altered state, he begins to read
meaning into this dehumanised, anatomical image:
'Devoid
of all context, even that of the body to which it belonged, the anus began to
assume an abstract quality. It became unmoored from functionality, from its
historicity, from all sense of reference. It was neither arousing nor
repulsive. I am tempted to suggest an affinity with Kant's 'thing-in-itself’.
In rapt free-association, I began to see in the anus intimations of a sublime
geometry'
As Nietzsche so
nearly said, ‘if you gaze long into an
anus, the anus also gazes into you’. Anus - Black Sun manages to capture the deadening aesthetic of extreme
pornography, the alienating effect of postmodern society and also our ability
to intellectualise and read meaning into any form of visual stimulus presented
to us. The nameless anus, and by extension Doyle’s story about it, becomes a
Rorschach test for the viewer; our psychological fixations reflected back to us
in the form of a gaping arsehole.
Many of the stories in This
Is The Ritual concern failed authors. These characters, inevitably ‘angry and self-marginalised’, have
singularly failed to transcend their surroundings, and been driven to the outer
edges of sanity by their attempts. One of the most memorable is John-Paul
Finnegan, would-be pioneer of the ‘paltry realism’ movement. According to one
of the few people to have seen it, his thirteen volume novel, Nevah Trust a Christian, was obviously 'written in great haste, utterly devoid of literary
flair' and 'displayed
not the slightest effort to entertain or seduce the reader'. Having failed
utterly to transform the literary world, he finds himself on board the ferry
Ulysses, on his way back to Ireland, railing against 'good taste... literary classicism.... the boredoms of morality and
plot - in other words, all the shit of literature'.
Projecting his self-loathing onto his fellow
passengers, he declares, 'If I were to
roar the word 'literature' at the top of my lungs, the vast majority of these
people would run to the sides of the ship and hurl themselves over the edge to
be drowned. They would sooner drown than confront a man roaring literature'.
Finnegan’s comment about ‘all the shit of literature’ refers back to a line in Doyle’s debut novel Here Are the Young Men, which portrays four adolescents determined to break free from ‘marriage, manners and money… the typical shit of literature’. That novel portrayed the exuberant, brutal iconoclasm of youth; This Is The Ritual looks at the aftermath. As one character says, 'being totally nihilistic is exciting when you're younger, you can get away with it then. There's still pleasure to be had in the destructive work. You haven't yet had to live in the ruins'.
Finnegan’s comment about ‘all the shit of literature’ refers back to a line in Doyle’s debut novel Here Are the Young Men, which portrays four adolescents determined to break free from ‘marriage, manners and money… the typical shit of literature’. That novel portrayed the exuberant, brutal iconoclasm of youth; This Is The Ritual looks at the aftermath. As one character says, 'being totally nihilistic is exciting when you're younger, you can get away with it then. There's still pleasure to be had in the destructive work. You haven't yet had to live in the ruins'.
In Ritual, the
ruins are all around: one character, a writer at the level of Sebald and Coetzee, emasculates himself, before ending his days decomposing
alone in his squalid flat, his hands and face eaten by his starving pet cat.
Drawn to extremes of form and subject, they are fighting an unwinnable battle
against convention and market diktats. Most end, like the fictional P Cranley,
enduring psychotic episodes, finding themselves outcasts even among the
subcultures of San Francisco.
There
is real ugliness in This Is The Ritual,
most notably in The Turk Inside.
Here, Doyle depicts the interior monologue of a jealous, possessive man who has
recently split up with his girlfriend, a stripper. The narrative quickly
descends into a screed of racism and misogyny, the knee-jerk reactions of a man
who views women as his property, and sees their exploitation by employers as a
crime against him, not them. We are left to question how many of the offences
he accuses his ex of are real, and how many are simply projections of his own
fear and disgust.
At
best, we see characters existing in a sort of resigned despair, as in On Nietzsche, a Geoff Dyer-esque account of a graduate who plans to write a
definitive biography of the philosopher, but is overwhelmed by the scale of the
task. He feels the need to write in order to 'confront and drive out the sense of total futility that had pervaded
my life and thoughts for more than a decade'. He finds himself confronting
the problem of boredom. Most pursuits are boring, he argues: even reading is
boring, though admittedly satisfying. Ultimately, he concludes, the problem is
that consciousness is boring. This knowledge is both liberating and paralysing.
The study of Nietzsche is a strain and a comfort - it is something to base his
life around, as long as he never has to actually work on it.
Blending
boundaries between fiction and memoir, Doyle often appears as a passive
narrator in his stories. Interspersed with traditional narratives are a series
of short, fragmentary pieces gathered together as Outposts: a sequence of jagged images of sex, death and delirium
repurposed from Bataille, Burroughs, conversations overheard by
the author in hospital wards and train carriages. The effect serves to
reinforce the book’s bleak portrayal of the human experience, showing that his
concerns cross the divides between fiction and life, high and low culture.
This Is The Ritual
is an unflinching examination of the darker areas of modern existence, of
people who fail to achieve the levels of self-actualisation to which we are
taught to aspire in Western society. Doyle’s style is uncompromising: at times
it feels as if he is challenging the reader to continue. The hedonism which
characterised the opening sections of Here
Are The Young Men is largely absent here, replaced with a catalogue of
despair and madness. And yet, the reader should carry on: Doyle is an author
who addresses important philosophical and literary themes, and makes them
integral to his work, rather than bolt-ons. He explores and acknowledges the
limitations of human endeavour, but also demonstrates that literature can
elevate our experiences beyond the constricts of ‘depressive realism’. This is
a rare skill, and one to be valued.

No comments:
Post a Comment